Planning a beach vacation is the easy part. After a full beach day, choosing the wrong dinner spot can disappoint families and couples, ending an otherwise great day. Old Orchard Beach has more pizza spots than most visitors expect, and knowing the best ones can improve your stay.

Food is central to the OOB experience, and pizza fits the rhythm of a beach town almost by design. Americans eat 46 pizza slices yearly, and Saturday night remains the most popular time for pizza at OOB. The boardwalk here has never had a shortage of options, but knowing which ones are worth your time is a different matter.

So, where do you actually go for the best pizza Old Orchard Beach has to offer this summer, and what should you know before you pick a spot?

Why Pizza and Old Orchard Beach Go Hand in Hand?

Old Orchard Beach has been a seasonal destination for generations of New England and Canadian families, and the boardwalk food culture reflects that history. Pizza suits every group size, travels easily to the beach, and stays affordable after a full day of activities.

What has changed since 2022 is the lineup. Rossetti’s Pizza now ranks number one near Old Orchard Beach on Yelp as of February 2026. Bella Pizza Pub climbed to fourth, while Bill’s Pizza and Lisa’s Pizza returned for another season. The pizza spots in Old Orchard Beach are more varied and competitive than they have been in years.

Guests at Seagrass Inn can walk to every pizza spot on this list from 50 West Grand Avenue. Families in King Suites can relax comfortably before heading out after a long beach day.

6 Best Pizza Spots in Old Orchard Beach 

Graphic listing six best pizza spots in Old Orchard Beach beside pizza photo.

Here is a deeper look at where to go, what makes each spot worth your time, and what to order when you get there.

1. Bill’s Pizza (The Maine Original)

For pizza in Old Orchard Beach, locals recommend Bill’s Pizza for its 77-year reputation. Open since 1949, Bill’s Pizza is one of the oldest continuously operating pizza spots in Maine. Pier French Fries acquired it in 2022, placing two iconic counter-service spots in OOB under one roof.

What Bill’s does is simple and deliberate: classic Maine-style pizza with a soft, slightly thicker crust, generous sauce, and straightforward toppings. There is no avant-garde menu here. You will find your pepperoni, your cheese, your sausage, done well and done consistently, the same way they have been for decades. The slices are large, the prices are fair, and the line moves quickly even when it is long.

Bill’s opened its 2025 season on May 2, starting with Friday through Sunday hours before expanding to seven days as summer picked up. Hours run 11 am to 8 pm through the peak season. For 2026, an opening has been announced on Facebook, with the exact date to be confirmed, so check their page before your first visit of the trip. Arrive before noon or after 2 pm on weekends to avoid the heaviest crowds near the pier.

2. Rocco’s Pizza (Best Reviewed Overall)

Anyone putting together a list of the best pizza spots in Old Orchard Beach will eventually land on Rocco’s, and for good reason. It is the spot that keeps coming up in reviews from people who have tried everything on the strip and come back having a clear favourite. With a 4.4 rating on TripAdvisor across 194 reviews, a 4.3 on Google across more than 770 reviews, and a strong showing on Yelp and the OneBite app, it is the most consistently reviewed pizza restaurant in the Old Orchard Beach area, and the reviews are specific in a way that matters.

Diners describe a thin, crispy New York-style crust that holds up under toppings without going soggy, a sauce-to-cheese ratio that gets called out repeatedly as just right, and a quality that stands out in a strip full of competing options. One family of seven reported returning to OOB every year specifically to eat at Rocco’s. Another reviewer from a May 2025 TripAdvisor post called it “one of the better pizza places in OOB’s fast food scene” for its flavourful cheese and crispy base. A MenuPix review from the same period called it “simply unbeatable.”

The menu at Rocco’s centres on its NY-style slices and whole pies, with classic topping combinations available alongside some seasonal or rotating options. It is a walk-up, counter-service format: order at the window, grab your box or plate, and find a spot nearby. Current confirmed hours are Monday through Thursday 11 am to 6 pm, Friday and Saturday 11 am to 9 pm, and Sunday 11 am to 7 pm. The Friday and Saturday late hours make it the go-to option if you are coming off a long evening at the beach or pier.

3. Lisa’s Pizza (Top Pick for Families)

For visitors specifically looking for the best pizza in Old Orchard Beach, Maine for a family outing, Lisa’s belongs at the top of the list. It is the kind of place that becomes a trip ritual for returning families, reliably good, consistently affordable, and positioned in exactly the right spot on the strip. It sits right next to Palace Playland, which means if you have children with you, there is a very good chance you are already walking past it multiple times a day.

What Lisa’s does well is volume and value. The portions are generous, the menu covers all the crowd-pleasing bases, including cheese, pepperoni, combination slices, and whole pies, and the pricing is among the most accessible on the strip without feeling like a sacrifice on quality. It won Silver in the Best of the 207 awards in the pizza category, which is a Maine-wide recognition that reflects real diner opinion rather than just local familiarity. On Facebook, Lisa’s has more than 4,900 likes and over 2,700 check-ins, which speaks to how embedded it is in the OOB visitor experience.

Current confirmed hours are Monday through Thursday 11 am to 7 pm, Friday and Saturday 11 am to 8 pm, and Sunday 11 am to 7 pm. The website copyright has been updated to 2026, confirming active operation this season. You can call ahead to (207) 934-7655, which is worth doing on busy summer afternoons if you want to time your pickup between activities without standing in line.

4. Rossetti’s Pizza (Yelp’s Current Number One)

Here is the pizza OOB, Maine visitors are largely not finding yet, and that is exactly the opportunity. As of February 2026, Rossetti’s Pizza holds the number one ranking on Yelp for pizza near Old Orchard Beach. It has a 100% recommendation rate from its reviewed guests on Facebook and was active and well-reviewed through at least October 2025. And yet, almost no editorial travel blog has written about it in any meaningful way.

What that means practically is this: most of the people following the usual OOB pizza guides are not walking through Rossetti’s door. People who find it tend to do so through Yelp or word of mouth, and they rate it highly. Rossetti’s served food and ice cream into October during the 2025 season. Its longer season benefits shoulder-season visitors to Old Orchard Beach.
Rossetti’s serves pizza and ice cream, making it especially convenient for families with children. If you are the kind of visitor who likes finding places the crowds have not caught up to yet, Rossetti’s is worth the short detour.

5. OTTO Pizza in Saco (Best for Creative Toppings)

OTTO is not on the OOB strip. Located in nearby Saco, it remains one of the best pizza spots in the Old Orchard Beach area. It consistently ranks in Yelp’s top three and offers something different from boardwalk pizza.

OTTO is a popular Maine pizza chain known for inventive toppings that go beyond traditional pizza menus. The mashed potato pizza combines potatoes, scallions, and bacon into a surprisingly popular pie, according to reviewers. Other creative combinations rotate through the menu, and the quality of ingredients is consistently noted in reviews.
The Saco location beside Apple IMAX makes dinner and a movie an easy evening plan near the inn. Yelp reviewers note friendly staff, a relaxed atmosphere, and the option to start with a Caesar salad before moving on to pizza. OTTO stays open year-round, making it the most reliable pizza option outside Old Orchard Beach’s summer season. If you are staying at Seagrass Inn in May, September, or October, OTTO is well worth the short drive.

6. Bella Pizza Pub (The Newcomer to Watch)

Bella Pizza Pub lacks a long history, but its growing reputation makes it one of the most-watched pizza spots in the area. It now ranks fourth on Yelp for pizza near Old Orchard Beach as of early 2026. Most editorial pizza guides ignored it before 2024. Strong rankings with little coverage often signal growing popularity driven by real guest experiences.

What sets Bella Pizza Pub apart from the strip’s walk-up counter culture is its pub-style format. It offers a sit-down bar atmosphere, unlike the quick counter-service style at Bill’s, Rocco’s, or Lisa’s. Bella Pizza Pub suits guests wanting table service, drinks, and a slower evening after the beach.

Because it is a newer entry, specific menu details and confirmed seasonal hours are worth verifying directly before your visit. Check current listings before visiting, but its Yelp ranking suggests it’s worth stopping.

One Last Slice of Advice Before You Head Out

One thing worth knowing before you head out: timing matters as much as the spot itself. Every place on this list gets significantly busier between 5 pm and 8 pm on weekends, so shifting your meal slightly outside that window makes a real difference. Hours can also shift week to week as summer builds, so a quick check of each spot’s social pages before you leave the inn is always worth it. Newer pizza spots in OOB now outrank longtime favorites on major review platforms. Checking current Yelp rankings beats relying on outdated travel guides.

If you are still sorting out where to stay, Seagrass Inn puts you 75 yards from the beach and within walking distance of nearly every spot on this list. The inn suits families and couples who want less driving and more time enjoying Old Orchard Beach. Guests can walk to the boardwalk, pier, and best pizza spots from the front door. Rooms book up quickly through the peak summer weeks, so if your dates are set, it is worth locking in sooner rather than later. Book now!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the best pizza in Old Orchard Beach right now?

Rossetti’s Pizza currently holds the top spot for pizza in Old Orchard Beach on Yelp. Rocco’s Pizza leads Google and TripAdvisor with 770+ reviews and a 4.3 rating. Bill’s Pizza has served the boardwalk since 1949 and remains Old Orchard Beach’s most iconic pizza institution. Your best pick depends on your taste, but all three are reliable starting points.

Are the best pizza spots in Old Orchard Beach walkable from the beach?

Most of them, yes. Bill’s, Rocco’s, and Lisa’s are all within easy walking distance of the sand, and Rossetti’s is a short detour from the main strip. The only exception on this list is OTTO Pizza, which is located in nearby Saco and requires a short drive. Guests staying at Seagrass Inn at 50 West Grand Avenue can walk to nearly every pizza spot on this list.

Is pizza in Old Orchard Beach, Maine available outside of summer?

A few spots are. OTTO Pizza in Saco operates year-round, making it the most reliable option for visitors in May, September, or October. Rossetti’s has also been noted to stay open into October, which makes it a good shoulder-season option. Most of the boardwalk spots, however, are seasonal, so confirming hours directly before your visit is always worth doing.

How do I find the best pizza spots in OOB, Maine without ending up in a long line?

Timing is the most practical tool. Pizza spots in OOB, Maine tend to peak between 5 pm and 8 pm on Friday and Saturday nights, when the bulk of visitors are finishing their beach day at the same time. Arriving before noon or after 8 pm, or visiting on a weekday, significantly reduces wait times. Checking each spot’s current hours on Facebook or Yelp before heading out is also a good habit, as hours can shift week to week through the season.