Choosing the perfect seafood spot in Old Orchard Beach can feel like a gamble—how do you know if you’re getting the real Maine experience? With so many options, it’s easy to wonder if you might miss the best of what this coastal town has to offer.
But what if you could cut through the noise and discover the spots that locals swear by? The search for the ultimate seafood dining experience starts here—and it’s more than worth the wait.
Shucks Maine Lobster
Shucks Maine Lobster is your go-to for fresh, wild-caught lobster and seafood that embodies the true taste of Maine. From lobster tails to raw lobster, they offer high-quality options perfect for home cooks and professional chefs alike. The company’s commitment to sustainability ensures you’re enjoying both great flavour and responsible sourcing.
What’s even better? Shucks offers a variety of delicious recipes, making it easy to prepare lobster dishes at home. Whether you’re craving classic Lobster Rolls or something a bit more adventurous, like Panko Crusted Lobster, there’s a recipe for every palate and cooking style.
Clambake Seafood Restaurant
Clambake Seafood Restaurant is a top seafood restaurant in OOB for fresh Maine seafood, offering a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere near Pine Point Beach. With daily seafood deliveries, guests can enjoy flavorful dishes like lobster rolls, clam chowder, and Fisherman’s Platters. The restaurant’s spacious setup, accommodating over 700 guests, ensures a comfortable dining experience with minimal wait times.
The diverse menu features fried haddock, baked seafood, salads, sandwiches, and kid-friendly options. Guests can stop by for a casual meal or a special gathering while enjoying generous portions and beautiful waterfront views.
Joseph’s by the Sea
Joseph’s by the Sea is a popular dining spot in Old Orchard Beach, offering stunning ocean views and a welcoming atmosphere. With over 50 years of history, it’s a favorite for both locals and visitors looking for a memorable coastal meal. Whether dining indoors or on the patio, guests can enjoy the fresh sea breeze and relaxing surroundings.
Their menu features fresh seafood like lobster, scallops, and locally sourced fish, along with brunch favorites and a curated bar selection. The rooftop dining area offers breathtaking views, where guests can savor dishes like lobster potato pancakes, seared sea scallops, and a classic Maine lobster roll.
The Bait Shed
The Bait Shed, located on the scenic Scarborough waterfront, offers a relaxed atmosphere where diners can enjoy freshly prepared seafood. Originally a historic bait cooler, the family-owned restaurant has been serving the community since 2012. Guests can soak in beautiful views of the Scarborough River while enjoying a variety of dishes, including lobster rolls, baked haddock, and clam chowder. The full bar adds to the dining experience, making it perfect for a casual meal with a drink in hand.
The menu features crowd favorites such as crab cakes, shrimp scampi flatbread, and a range of daily specials. In addition to seafood, there are tasty sides like French fries, onion rings, and coleslaw. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic seafood boil or a light lobster salad, The Bait Shed offers something to satisfy every seafood lover’s cravings.
Ken’s Place
Ken’s Place in Scarborough, Maine, has been a local favorite for nearly 100 years, serving up fresh seafood in a laid-back, family-friendly atmosphere. The menu features classic Maine dishes like fried clams, lobster rolls, and a raw bar with fresh oysters and clams. For those looking for a hearty meal, the Fisherman’s Platter is a must-try, loaded with fried fish, scallops, small shrimp, and crispy fries.
This restaurant in OOB is all about quick service, with counter-ordering to keep things moving. While the food is praised for its freshness, some visitors suggest trying the half-and-half batter for a perfect balance of crispiness. Don’t forget to pair your meal with their homemade tartar sauce for an extra boost of flavor. Ken’s Place is a staple in Maine’s seafood scene, offering a delicious, no-frills dining experience.
The Lobster Claw Pound & Restaurant
The Lobster Claw Pound & Restaurant in Saco, Maine, has been serving delicious, freshly prepared seafood for over 40 years. The family-owned spot is well-loved for its casual vibe and warm, welcoming atmosphere. Guests can enjoy a wide variety of seafood dishes, including lobster rolls, fried clams, and classic New England clam chowder, all made with the finest local ingredients.
Perfect for families and seafood enthusiasts, the restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating options, making it a great year-round destination. With a menu full of mouthwatering options, it’s a must-visit spot for anyone craving a true taste of Maine.
The Shack
The Shack, located in Old Orchard Beach, offers a laid-back atmosphere with a two-story dining experience and beachfront views. Known for their best lobster rolls in Old Orchard Beach, tempura lobster roll, and other seafood dishes, the restaurant serves up fresh, flavorful meals with a variety of specialty drinks. Guests can relax on the deck while enjoying the view of the beach, making it a perfect spot to unwind with delicious seafood.
The menu also features popular options like lobster mac and cheese and clam chowder, with something for every seafood lover. Despite some minor critiques regarding cleanliness, many visitors praise the fantastic food and friendly service, making The Shack a must-visit in the area.
Mainely Lobster Cafe
Mainely Lobster Cafe, located in South Portland, offers a casual and welcoming atmosphere perfect for enjoying fresh, high-quality seafood. Although not right on the beach, the restaurant is situated on a busy main road, making it an excellent spot for people-watching while savoring signature dishes. Customers rave about the famous lobster rolls, served either with butter or garlic aioli, along with other delicious options like lobster mac and cheese and New England clam chowder.
The menu also features crispy haddock, grilled chicken sandwiches, and tuna poke bowls, providing variety for those seeking something beyond lobster. The outdoor seating area with umbrellas creates a relaxing environment to enjoy your meal. With its friendly service and affordable prices, Mainely Lobster Cafe is a must-visit for anyone craving fresh seafood in a laid-back setting.
Bayley’s Lobster Pound
Bayley’s Lobster Pound offers an authentic Maine seafood experience with breathtaking views of the water. Known for its delicious and fresh lobsters, visitors rave about the classic Maine fishery vibe, which adds to the charm of the place. The outdoor seating is a great spot to enjoy signature dishes such as lobster rolls and the popular Lazy Man lobster, while the friendly staff ensures a welcoming atmosphere.
The menu also features a variety of seafood options, including whole lobsters and baked stuffed lobster. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a loyal customer, Bayley’s Lobster Pound promises a memorable meal.
Bell Buoy Restaurant
The Bell Buoy Restaurant in Old Orchard Beach is a well-loved local spot that serves up delicious New England seafood in a friendly, relaxed setting. Guests rave about their clam chowder, lazy lobster twin meal, and other seafood staples like scallops and stuffed shrimp.
The restaurant also offers generous portions at affordable prices, with fixed-price 3-course meals that give visitors a taste of everything. The staff, known for their excellent service, add to the warm and welcoming vibe of this popular family-style restaurant. The Bell Buoy is particularly praised for its flavorful fried lobster appetizer and calamari, along with its attentive bartenders and servers.
The atmosphere is perfect for both casual dinner in Old Orchard Beach and special occasions. Visitors can expect to enjoy hearty, comforting meals, with the added bonus of a scenic coastal vibe that makes dining at the Bell Buoy truly special. If you’re in the area, it’s a must-visit for great seafood and a fun, memorable experience.
Taste the Best Seafood, Stay at Seagrass Inn
Old Orchard Beach is a treasure trove for seafood lovers, offering a dining experience that’s as authentic as it gets. Each restaurant brings something unique to the table—looking for a laid-back meal by the beach or a special gathering with loved ones, you’ll find it here. Every spot on this list brings something worth remembering, from breathtaking views to flavors that will transport you straight to the heart of Maine’s coastal cuisine.
Looking to make the most of your seafood adventure? Seagrass Inn offers the perfect retreat, just a stone’s throw away from these incredible dining spots. With its cozy atmosphere and prime location, it’s the ideal place to relax and enjoy the true essence of Old Orchard Beach, all while being close to the best seafood restaurants in the area. Book now!
FAQs
What seafood sandwich is Maine known for?
There’s no better way to celebrate summer in New England than with a lobster roll. While Connecticut’s warm, buttered version has its charm, Maine’s take on this iconic seafood sandwich—featuring a toasted bun, cold lobster, and mayo—is truly legendary. After all, lobster and Maine go hand in hand.
Why is seafood so expensive in Maine?
Lobster prices in Old Orchard Beach change based on supply and demand. Seasonal weather and sea conditions also affect costs. However, one thing remains clear: Maine lobster is in high demand worldwide. This global popularity is the key driver behind the price variations.
Why is lobster famous in Maine?
There are 49 lobster species worldwide. The Maine lobster is the most popular for its sweet, tender meat. The cold waters of the Northeast give Maine lobsters a less salty taste compared to other varieties.
What is Maine famous for besides lobster?
Maine is famous for its stunning coastlines, national parks, and rich history. The state has grand mansions and iconic lighthouses. And, every spot is unique and holds its own story. For many, dining in Maine instantly brings to mind its famous lobster.
