A day at Old Orchard Beach isn’t complete without a cold, creamy scoop of ice cream. After hours of sun, sand, and ocean breeze, there’s nothing better than treating yourself to a cone, sundae, or towering soft-serve. But with so many ice cream spots around, how do you know which ones are actually worth the stop?
Some places pile on the toppings, others serve massive portions, and a few offer homemade flavors you won’t find anywhere else. So where can you find the best frozen treats near Old Orchard Beach?
1. The Dairy Corner
The Dairy Corner in Scarborough, Maine, has been serving up frozen treats since 1979, turning an old gas station into a beloved local ice cream stand. With over 70 flavors of hard and soft serve, plus frozen yogurt and dairy-free options, there’s something for everyone. Their unique treats, like ice cream pizzas—chocolate chip cookie bases piled with ice cream, candy, and hot fudge—make them stand out among the best ice cream spots in the area.
Add a spacious backyard patio with Adirondack chairs, and it’s the perfect spot to enjoy a cone on a warm summer night. Just a short drive from Old Orchard Beach, The Dairy Corner is a go-to stop for beachgoers looking to cool off with a sweet treat. Open seasonally from April to October, it’s known for its nostalgic charm and wide variety of flavors, including locally made ice cream. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this spot is a must-visit when the weather warms up again in April 2025.
2. Fielder’s Choice Ice Cream
If you’re on the hunt for top-tier ice cream near Old Orchard Beach, Fielder’s Choice Ice Cream is a must-visit. This family-owned spot on Saco Ave has been serving up homemade, high-quality treats since 2006. Their menu is stacked with both hard and soft serve flavors, from classics like Mint Chocolate Chip to unique picks like Almond Joy and Baked Indian Pudding. It’s one of the standout ice cream spots downtown, drawing both locals and visitors with its generous portions and rich flavors.
If you’re looking for something dairy-free, they’ve got refreshing sorbet options too. And if you’re all about over-the-top indulgence, their Dugout Floor™ Sundae—loaded with hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, and Reese’s—won’t disappoint. People rave about the massive portions and fresh-baked add-ons like brownies and cookies. Plus, they’re open year-round, so you don’t have to wait for summer to get your fix. Just a heads-up—it’s cash only, but there’s an ATM on-site. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, Fielder’s Choice Ice Cream is the kind of place that keeps you coming back for more.
3. Big Licks Ice Cream
Nestled in the heart of Old Orchard Beach, Big Licks Ice Cream is a must-visit destination for ice cream enthusiasts. Renowned for its generous portions and an impressive array of over 80 flavors, this charming shop crafts its super-premium ice cream on-site daily, ensuring every scoop is fresh and flavorful.
From classic options like French Vanilla and Mint Chocolate Chip to unique creations such as Maine Maple Bacon and Cookie Monster, there’s something to delight every palate. Their menu also features specialty sundaes, frappes, and freshly baked ice cream cookie sandwiches, making it a paradise for dessert lovers. Visitors consistently praise Big Licks for its rich, creamy textures and diverse offerings. With its convenient location at 8 West Grand Avenue and a welcoming atmosphere, Big Licks Ice Cream stands out as a top spot near Old Orchard Beach to indulge in delightful frozen treats.
4. Dairy Queen
If you’re exploring Old Orchard Beach and have a craving for some classic ice cream treats, the local Dairy Queen at 12 Old Orchard Street is a spot worth visiting. Known for its iconic soft-serve cones and signature Blizzard® Treats, this DQ® location offers a delightful break from the sun and sand. Whether you’re in the mood for a simple vanilla cone or a more indulgent treat like the Strawberry Cheesecake Blizzard®, there’s something for every ice cream lover.
Visitors often praise the friendly and efficient service at this Dairy Queen. So, if you’re compiling a list of top ice cream spots near Old Orchard Beach, this Dairy Queen certainly deserves a spot. If you’re compiling a list of good ice cream spots near Old Orchard Beach, this Dairy Queen certainly deserves a spot.
5. Bill’s Pizza & Ice Cream
Bill’s Pizza is a downtown staple, best known for its delicious slices, but their ice cream selection is equally worth mentioning. Combining two beach-day essentials—pizza and ice cream—this spot is a great place for families or groups who can’t decide between savory and sweet. They offer a variety of hand-scooped flavors, from rich chocolate to refreshing fruit-based options, all served in classic waffle cones.
One of the best things about Bill’s is its prime location. Right in the heart of Old Orchard Beach, it’s an easy stop while exploring the pier and boardwalk. It’s a laid-back, no-frills spot where you can grab a slice, a cone, and enjoy the lively beach atmosphere all in one go.
6. Ocean Park Ice Cream
Tucked away in the quieter Ocean Park community, this shop offers a more relaxed setting compared to the bustling boardwalk. They serve high-quality, locally made ice cream with unique flavors like black raspberry chip, coconut almond joy, and even maple walnut. Their waffle cones are made fresh, adding an extra level of indulgence to every scoop.
What makes Ocean Park Ice Cream stand out is its charm. The small, cozy atmosphere makes it a perfect stop after a quiet beach walk. Unlike some of the busier spots in town, this location offers a peaceful retreat where you can sit back and truly enjoy your ice cream without feeling rushed.
7. Martel’s Ice Cream
A little further out in Saco, Martel’s is a family-owned gem that has been serving homemade ice cream for decades. They’re known for their creamy texture and deep flavors, which range from classic vanilla bean to creative choices like caramel pretzel crunch. Their sundaes, topped with homemade hot fudge and real whipped cream, are a must-try for any dessert lover.
Martel’s also features an outdoor seating area surrounded by greenery, making it an ideal place to sit and enjoy a cone on a warm summer evening. The commitment to using fresh ingredients and keeping their menu interesting has helped them build a strong reputation beyond just Saco—many Old Orchard Beach visitors make the trip just for a taste.
8. Gelato Supreme Candy Shop & Ice Cream
Gelato Supreme Candy Shop & Ice Cream is a fun spot in Old Orchard Beach. It serves a variety of frozen treats and sweets. Located at 26 Old Orchard Street, this shop has become a favorite among locals and tourists alike. They serve a variety of gelato flavors, providing a refreshing alternative to traditional ice cream. The shop has a variety of candies alongside its gelato selection. It’s a perfect stop for anyone craving something sweet.
Visitors appreciate the nostalgic ambiance and the extensive selection of treats available. The shop sits near the beach, making it an easy stop for a refreshing treat. It’s perfect for cooling off after a sunny day. Craving a scoop of creamy gelato or some classic candies? This spot offers a sweet experience that adds to Old Orchard Beach’s charm.
Scoop Up a Treat and Relax at Seagrass Inn
With so many great ice cream spots near Old Orchard Beach, choosing where to go can be tough. Some serve giant sundaes packed with toppings, while others focus on small-batch, locally made flavors. From classic cones to creative treats, each spot adds to the charm of a perfect beach day.
After indulging, unwind at Seagrass Inn—just steps from the beach, the pier, and top ice cream shops. With cozy accommodations in a prime spot, it’s a great place to unwind after a beach day. Enjoy some rest after soaking up the sun, sand, and local treats. Book now and make the most of your stay!
FAQs
What is the best time to visit ice cream shops near Old Orchard Beach?
Most ice cream spots are busiest in the afternoon and evening, especially during summer. Visiting earlier in the day can help avoid long lines.
Do any ice cream shops near Old Orchard Beach stay open year-round?
Many ice cream shops are seasonal, but some stay open year-round. Fielder’s Choice Ice Cream offers frozen treats even in winter.
Are there any unique or must-try ice cream flavors in the area?
Many local shops feature unique flavors like Maine blueberry, maple walnut, and bourbon caramel swirl. Others offer fun options like brownie batter.
Are there ice cream shops near Old Orchard Beach that offer more than just ice cream?
Yes! Some spots also serve baked goods, sundaes, milkshakes, and even ice cream sandwiches made with fresh cookies or waffles.
Leave A Comment